Blog · 2026-11-16

Salary, dividend or director's loan: what ₹1 lakh really costs to withdraw

Compare the real tax cost of director remuneration, dividend and a director's loan in FY 2026-27, with worked numbers, section 2(22)(e) risk and the entries.

Updated for FY 2026-27 (AY 2027-28).

Salary, dividend or a director's loan: what each ₹1 lakh really costs to pull out of your private limited company

You own the company, the money is sitting in the current account, and you need ₹5 lakh for a personal expense. The three obvious routes — pay yourself remuneration, declare a dividend, or simply transfer it and call it a loan — carry very different tax bills, and the lazy third option is the one that creates problems at assessment. This piece works the numbers for FY 2026-27 and shows the entries to pass so your books agree with your TDS returns.

First check what the company already owes you

Before any tax planning, open the director's current account in your ledger. In most small companies the founder has put money in — seed capital, a laptop bought on a personal card, a vendor advance paid from a savings account, rent paid personally during the first months. Repaying that balance is a return of your own money. It is not income, there is no TDS, and there is no company deduction to argue about.

The same goes for genuine reimbursements of business expenses incurred personally. These need supporting bills attached to the voucher, not a round-sum "expenses ₹25,000" entry. A round sum with no bills is remuneration in substance and will be taxed as such.

Practical step: pull the general ledger for the director's current account for the last three years, list every credit, and confirm you have the bank statement line or bill behind each one. Whatever survives that test can be paid out first, at zero tax cost.

Route 1: director remuneration

Remuneration is generally deductible for the company as a business expense (under provisions such as section 37(1) of the Income Tax Act, which your CA can confirm), provided it is genuine and reasonable for the services rendered, backed by a board resolution and (for an employee-director) an appointment letter. In your hands it is salary, taxed at slab rates, with TDS deducted under section 192 at your average rate and reported in Form 24Q every quarter.

Two features matter under the default new regime:

If a working family member genuinely renders services, salary to them is deductible too, and under the new regime their tax is nil where total income does not exceed ₹12 lakh because of the rebate under section 87A. The word doing the work there is "genuinely" — an unexplained salary to a non-working relative is disallowed and attracts penalty.

Remember that salary brings payroll obligations with it: PF and ESI where applicable, and monthly TDS deposits. Director's sitting fees or professional fees paid to a non-executive director fall under section 194J instead, with TDS at 10% once the annual payment crosses ₹50,000.

Route 2: dividend, taxed twice by design

A dividend is paid out of post-tax profit. The company has already paid corporate tax on that profit — 25% where turnover is up to ₹400 crore, or 22% under section 115BAA if you have opted in without exemptions, plus surcharge where applicable and 4% cess. You then pay tax again on the dividend at your slab rate, with no standard deduction. TDS applies on dividend payments above a small threshold; check the current rate and threshold with your CA.

Work out the combined marginal cost. Under 115BAA with cess and no surcharge, the company keeps ₹77.12 out of every ₹100. If your personal marginal rate is 30% plus 4% cess, you keep 68.8% of that ₹77.12 — ₹53.06. The effective cost is roughly 46.9%. The same ₹100 paid as salary costs you 31.2% at the same marginal rate.

That is the whole argument. For a reasonable, deductible salary, dividend is never the cheaper route for the same person. Dividend becomes relevant when salary cannot be justified — a passive shareholder who does no work, a co-founder who has left operations, or where you want distributions to follow shareholding rather than effort.

Route 3: a loan from the company

Transferring money and parking it in "loan to director" feels free because nothing hits the profit and loss account. It is not free.

A short, properly documented, interest-bearing loan that is actually repaid is a legitimate tool. A permanent debit balance that grows every year is an assessment waiting to happen.

Worked example: ₹30 lakh of profit, three ways

A private limited company has ₹30,00,000 of profit before any director payout, has opted for section 115BAA (22% plus 4% cess, no surcharge at this income level), and has one working director with no other income, taxed under the new regime.

All as remuneration. Company profit after salary is nil, so no corporate tax. Total income is ₹30,00,000 − ₹75,000 = ₹29,25,000. Slab tax: ₹20,000 (₹4–8 lakh) + ₹40,000 (₹8–12 lakh) + ₹60,000 (₹12–16 lakh) + ₹80,000 (₹16–20 lakh) + ₹1,00,000 (₹20–24 lakh) + ₹1,57,500 (30% on ₹5,25,000) = ₹4,57,500, plus 4% cess ₹18,300 = ₹4,75,800. Cash in hand ₹25,24,200. Overall cost 15.9%.

All as dividend. Corporate tax at 22.88% on ₹30,00,000 = ₹6,86,400, leaving ₹23,13,600 to distribute. Personal tax on ₹23,13,600 with no standard deduction: ₹20,000 + ₹40,000 + ₹60,000 + ₹80,000 + 25% on ₹3,13,600 (₹78,400) = ₹2,78,400, plus cess ₹11,136 = ₹2,89,536. Cash in hand ₹20,24,064. Total tax ₹9,75,936, or 32.5%.

Salary of ₹12,75,000, balance as dividend. Company tax on ₹17,25,000 = ₹3,94,680, distributable ₹13,30,320. Personal total income is salary income (₹12,75,000 - ₹75,000) + dividend income (₹13,30,320) = ₹25,30,320. Tax on this is ₹3,39,096 plus cess = ₹3,52,660. Cash in hand ₹22,52,660. Worse than pure salary by about ₹2.7 lakh, because every rupee moved from salary to dividend loses the company's deduction.

The split only becomes interesting where salary would be hard to defend as reasonable, or where the payout must follow shareholding.

Book it properly, or the saving disappears

Remuneration of ₹1,00,000 with ₹10,000 TDS under section 192:

Account Dr Cr
Director remuneration 1,00,000
TDS payable – 192 10,000
Director's current account 90,000

Dividend of ₹5,00,000 declared:

Account Dr Cr
Retained earnings 5,00,000
Dividend payable 5,00,000

A loan of ₹2,00,000 goes to a balance-sheet account, never to an expense head:

Account Dr Cr
Loan to director 2,00,000
Bank 2,00,000

Three routines keep this clean: deposit TDS and file 24Q/26Q each quarter; reconcile the bank monthly so no director transfer sits unclassified; and revise your advance tax instalments once the payout is decided — 15% by 15 June, 45% by 15 September, 75% by 15 December and 100% by 15 March, with interest under sections 234B and 234C on any shortfall. A large dividend declared in March with no advance tax paid is an expensive surprise.

Doing this in FlipAccounts

Create a separate ledger for each director under Chart of Accounts — "Director's current account", "Loan to director" and "Director remuneration" — so the three routes never blur into one line. Use the bank reconciliation screen to import your statement and tag every transfer to the right one; the categorisation rules will remember the pattern for next month. The TDS summary shows what you have deducted under 192, 194J and 194I, ready for your quarterly return, and the statements pack gives the P&L and balance sheet your auditor will ask for. Personal tax computation under both regimes sits in the same account, so you can test a salary figure against the slabs before passing the entry. Core accounting is free, with no card and no limits — sign up at https://platform.flipaccounts.app/?signup=1.

Your checklist now

  1. Review your ledger. Check the director's current account for any past loans or expenses paid personally. Repaying these is tax-free.
  2. Pass a board resolution. Document any remuneration decision formally before you pay it.
  3. Check TDS and advance tax. Ensure TDS on the chosen route is deducted correctly and deposited on time. Re-calculate your company and personal advance tax liability for the next instalment.
  4. Keep it clean. Don't mix loans, salary and reimbursements in one account. Create separate ledgers to maintain a clear audit trail.

Frequently asked questions

Is salary always better than dividend for a director?

For a working director, salary is almost always more tax-efficient. This is because salary is a deductible expense for the company, reducing its corporate tax bill. Dividends are paid out of profits on which the company has already paid tax, leading to double taxation on the same pool of money.

What happens if I just transfer money from the company without documentation?

The tax authorities can treat an undocumented withdrawal as a 'deemed dividend' to the extent of the company's accumulated profits, and tax it in your hands at your slab rate. It can also violate the Companies Act, which has strict rules about loans to directors, potentially leading to penalties.

Can I pay a salary to my spouse or a family member?

Yes, provided they are genuinely working for the company and the salary is reasonable for the services they provide. You must maintain proper documentation like an appointment letter and proof of work. A salary paid to a non-working relative will be disallowed as an expense for the company and can attract penalties.

Do I need to pay advance tax on dividend income?

Yes. Dividend income is taxed at your slab rate. It must be included in your total income when calculating your advance tax liability for the year. Failing to pay adequate advance tax can lead to interest charges under sections 234B and 234C.

Keep your books this way, free

FlipAccounts does the bookkeeping underneath everything above. No card, no limits.

Create your free account

More guides